What kind of roof do you currently have? If you’re like most Minnesotans, and most Americans, you’ve got asphalt shingles. That said, what about slate tile roofs? Maybe you’re thinking of having a new roof installed and you’re ready for a change. So, should you stick with asphalt or try slate tiles? Which one is best?

It’s time to compare asphalt shingles and slate tile roofs…

#1 The Cost Of Asphalt Shingle Vs. Slate Tile:

Asphalt Shingle Vs The Slate Tile

When you are scrutinizing the overall cost of both asphalt and slate roofing materials, it is important to consider two major parameters — the cost of installation and the cost of the overall maintenance over a certain course of time. For every homeowner, it’s essential to have a proper budget under which he/she can manage the installation of the roof and maintain it in the years to come. 

When asphalt shingles are compared to slate tile shingles on the cost factor, then it is recommended that you opt for asphalt shingle roofing systems. This is because the asphalt shingles are less expensive than the slate tile roofing system. Even the labor work and installation process costs would be significantly lower for asphalt shingles. So, if you are tight on budget, then asphalt shingles would be the right option for you.

#2 The Average Age Of The Asphalt Shingle Roof Vs. The Slate Tile Roof:

Lifespan of Asphalt Shingle Roof and Slate Tile Roof

This is yet another important factor that plays a key role when choosing the right roofing material for your house. If you are going for asphalt shingles, there are three major layers or tabs of the asphalt shingles which increase the service life expectancy of the roof to about 30 to 35 years. If you have the option of just one tab or 2 tabs, then the service life would be around 20 years. Now if you compare the asphalt shingles with slate tiles, you would learn that slate tiles have a greater service life than asphalt shingles. The average service life of slate tile is approximately 100 years or even more! Slate tile roofing might have a high initial cost but if you consider the long-term pricing then it seems to be very economical. 

#3 Consider The Appearance Factor Of Both Roofing Systems: 

If you compare both roofing systems, then you would see that slate tile roofing systems are considered to be one of the best and most beautiful roofing materials on the market today. It imparts a classic and unique rustic charm to the roof and the entire house. Slates in dark gray or black are most popular among homeowners. These colors have the potential to complement the look of the entire house and increase its value as well. While asphalt shingles can look good, slate tiles look great! 


Both asphalt shingles and slate tile roofing materials make a house look good and protect it from the elements. That said, some people prefer asphalt because it’s cheaper, while others prefer slate tile because, looks-wise, it stands out more. Not sure which one you’d prefer? Talk with Arko Exteriors. Please call 763-434-2756 or use the online contact page, here: https://arkoexteriors.com/contact-us/